Monday, September 26, 2016

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

In the article False Confessions, they talk about how sleep deprivation is a key component to people falsely accusing themselves in crimes they didn’t commit, this happens in 15-25% of cases. This leads to a lot of innocent people been convicted and either spending a lot of time incarcerated or put to death for crimes they didn’t commit.

The study consisted of 88 students from Michigan State University who completed 3 laboratory sessions. In the first session they gave their basic information and they were given the instructions on how to go about the procedure, specifically the importance of not pressing the Escape Key on the keyboard. The button was located on the top left corner making it pretty hard to press. During the second session (7 days later) where the participants rated their sleepiness and were shown the warning again then half of the participants slept for 8 hours in the lab and others stayed awake. Then they completed another set of procedures and questionnaires. This took place a 3rd day, after all the testing was complete the participants were asked to sign a statement which accused them of pressing the escape key some signed the form the first time but some took until the second time to sign the statement.

The experimenters found that sleep-deprived participants reported increased sleepiness and an increase in positive and negative effects than the rested participants, meaning that the sleep-deprived participants were more likely to sign the statement then the rested participants.


This study is can greatly affect the general public specifically law enforcement. If they decided to change the way they interrogate suspects in a different setting as well as during a different time of day and not for as many hours, then they would probably less people that would admit to crimes and less people losing years of the lives in jail.

1 comment:

  1. I read this article as well, for my Monday blog, and was shocked about a stat in it that said false confessions increased to 50% agreement in the sleep-deprived student group as compared to 18% in the rested group after the initial signing request. 50% is an alarmingly high percentage in my opinion, and if students are admitting to "crimes" they didn't commit in a study, what about sleep-deprived suspects already subjected to the stresses of their trial? I would like to see more research performed into interrogation practices in our federal justice system, and I would also like to see more regulations enforced on interrogation practices (i.e. as you said, only questioning during certain hours, for limited durations, etc.)

    ReplyDelete